A national insurance cut for under-25s is the centrepiece of a report due to be published this week by former Labour minister Alan Milburn. According to early reports, it recommends gradually reducing employment costs for young workers over five years. The aim is to make hiring a young person cheaper and less risky for employers, and so to bring down the number of young people outside work and education. This article treats the proposal as a process. It looks at the problem being targeted, how the mechanism would operate step by step, where it could fail, and what to watch for as the detail emerges.
Only the headline outline has been reported so far. Rates, thresholds, costings and timing are not yet public, so this analysis separates established facts about the current system from interpretation of how a reform might behave.
The problem the report is trying to solve
The proposal comes from a review of young people who are not in education, employment or training (NEET). The Office for National Statistics estimated the UK’s NEET population aged 16 to 24 at roughly 950,000 in early 2025, close to one in eight young people. Check the latest Office for National Statistics release for current figures, because they are revised regularly.
Economists worry about this group because long spells out of work early in a career can scar later earnings and employment prospects. Rising youth unemployment also matters for public finances, since lost earnings mean lost tax receipts and higher spending on benefits such as Universal Credit. The government commissioned the review, and the Milburn report on youth unemployment is its main output.
Why employer costs are in the frame
Employers pay National Insurance contributions on top of wages, and from April 2025 the main employer rate rose from 13.8% to 15% while the threshold at which it applies fell from £9,100 to £5,000 per year. Official rates are set out on GOV.UK. Combined with increases to the National Minimum Wage, this raised the cost of hiring entry-level staff, a pattern that business groups in hospitality and retail have described publicly. Whether it is the main cause of weak youth hiring is contested, and the report’s reasoning will need to deal with that.
How the current system treats young workers
Understanding the proposal requires knowing what already exists. Employers pay no secondary Class 1 contributions on earnings up to a set upper threshold for employees under 21, and the same relief applies to apprentices under 25. A 22-year-old non-apprentice therefore costs more in tax than a 20-year-old doing the same job.
An illustrative calculation shows the gap. On a £25,000 salary, employer contributions are 15% of the amount above £5,000, which is £3,000 a year. Under-21s attract none of that, so the cliff edge at 21 is already a design feature. Extending relief to 25 would move that cliff edge, which is why the five-year phase-in matters.
How a gradual reduction would work, step by step
The reported design, a gradual cut over five years, implies a staged process. The detail below is inference from how such policies normally operate, not confirmed content of the report.
Step 1: Define the eligible group
The government would set an age test, probably based on the employee’s age on a given date, as the current under-21 rule is. This is the simplest part administratively, because payroll software already handles age-based National Insurance categories.
Step 2: Set the phase-down path
A five-year schedule could lower the employer rate for under-25s in annual steps. It could also widen the zero-rate band year by year. The choice affects the economics. A rate cut helps all eligible employers equally. A threshold change helps low-paid roles most, which is where young people concentrate.
Step 3: Employers change hiring behaviour
This is the step that decides whether jobs appear. A lower cost of hiring a 23-year-old can show up in three ways:
- More vacancies opened or filled, which is the intended effect.
- Higher pay for young staff, if employers pass savings on.
- Higher margins, if firms keep the saving and hire no one extra.
This is the tax incidence question, and in competitive low-wage markets the outcome depends on how binding the minimum wage is. Where wages are pinned at the legal floor, savings cannot become higher pay, so they are more likely to affect hiring or profits.
Step 4: Fiscal costing and scrutiny
The Office for Budget Responsibility would estimate the revenue loss, and HM Treasury would need to find offsetting savings or revenue, especially under tight fiscal rules set by Chancellor Rachel Reeves. Independent analysts such as the Institute for Fiscal Studies typically examine such measures for cost per job created. No official costing has been published for this plan, so any figure circulating before then should be treated cautiously.
Step 5: Evaluate and adjust
A phased policy allows the government to monitor outcomes between stages. In theory it can slow, accelerate or redesign later steps if early evidence is poor, which is one of the strongest arguments for phasing.
Does cutting national insurance create jobs?
The honest answer is: sometimes, and less than headlines suggest. Evidence from payroll-tax and wage subsidy schemes in several countries is mixed. Targeted subsidies for young or long-term unemployed workers have produced measurable hiring gains in some studies, particularly when employers see the support as lasting. Other evaluations found large deadweight effects, meaning firms received support for hires they would have made anyway.
Main risks and edge cases
- Displacement: employers may hire a 24-year-old instead of a 26-year-old, shifting unemployment up the age range rather than reducing it.
- The new cliff edge: if the relief ends at 25, firms might churn staff at that birthday. A taper reduces but does not remove this.
- Wrong target group: many NEET young people have health problems, caring responsibilities or low qualifications. A cheaper hire does not address those barriers on its own.
- Graduate versus low-skill split: a flat cut benefits graduate employers as much as those hiring school leavers, unless the threshold is designed to favour lower pay.
What the policy needs alongside the tax cut
A fair reading of the review’s remit is that tax is one lever among several. Practical complements include:
- Better support through Jobcentre Plus and local services, including health and mental health support.
- Stronger links between further education, apprenticeships and local employers.
- Clear guarantees of a job, training place or education, as in youth guarantee schemes elsewhere in Europe.
- Simple rules that small employers can understand without payroll specialists.
Without these, a tax cut risks rewarding the young people who were already easiest to employ.
Political and economic context
The proposal lands in a politically sensitive place. The Chancellor’s decision to raise employer contributions in the 2024 Budget attracted criticism, and a targeted rollback for the young could be read as a partial correction. Health Secretary Wes Streeting, Keir Starmer‘s government and the Treasury will each weigh cost against political benefit. Whether to adopt the recommendation is a government decision, and reports of this kind are not binding.
There is also a wider debate about payroll taxes as a tool. Supporters argue that taxing jobs discourages hiring, so cutting the tax for a vulnerable group is efficient. Critics respond that narrow cuts create distortions and complexity, and that money would do more good spent directly on training and support. Both positions are defensible, and the answer depends on design and empirical results.
What employers and young jobseekers should do now
Nothing changes until legislation passes, probably through a Budget. In the meantime:
- Employers should model hiring costs under several scenarios and avoid assuming a specific rate or start date.
- Payroll teams should check how age-based National Insurance categories are handled in their software, since extension to 25 would change the category logic.
- Young jobseekers should not wait. Existing apprenticeship incentives and the under-21 relief remain in force.
- Advisers and local authorities should track the report for recommendations on support services, which may arrive sooner than tax changes.
Frequently asked questions
What is the Milburn report on youth unemployment?
It is a review led by Alan Milburn into why so many young people are not in work, education or training, and what government and employers can do about it. It is reported to recommend cutting employer National Insurance for under-25s gradually over five years.
Would young workers pay less National Insurance themselves?
The reported proposal concerns employment costs, which points to employer contributions. Employee contributions have not been reported as part of it, but the final text will confirm this.
When would the change take effect?
No date has been announced. Tax changes normally need to be announced in a Budget and legislated for, so a start date would probably be at least several months away.
Who is a NEET?
NEET stands for not in education, employment or training, and is the standard statistical category for young people who are neither working nor studying.
The test that will decide whether the plan works
The most important insight is that the five-year gradual design is both the policy’s greatest strength and its greatest weakness. Phasing makes the cost manageable and allows evidence-based adjustment. It also delays the signal to employers, and a benefit that arrives slowly may not change hiring decisions today. Firms respond to certainty, so a credible, legislated schedule could matter more than the final rate.
Watch for three things. First, the OBR costing and the cost per additional job it implies. Second, whether the design tackles the age-25 cliff edge. Third, whether the government pairs the tax cut with funded support for the young people furthest from work. A reasonable prediction is that the measure will help the already job-ready most, and that its success will depend on whether the support for the hardest-to-reach group is funded alongside it. The open question is whether a policy built on cheaper hiring can reach the young people who need more than a cheaper hiring cost.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Milburn national insurance cut for under-25s already confirmed policy?
No. Only a headline outline has been reported so far. Rates, thresholds, costings and timing are not public. The report recommends a gradual reduction over five years, but the government has to decide whether to adopt it, so details could change.
Do employers already get any national insurance relief for hiring young people?
Yes. Employers pay no secondary Class 1 contributions on earnings up to an upper threshold for employees under 21, and the same relief covers apprentices under 25. Extending it to all under-25s would move the existing cliff edge at 21 to a later age.
How much could an employer save on a young worker's salary?
On a £25,000 salary, employer contributions are 15% of the amount above £5,000, which is £3,000 a year. Under-21s already attract none of this. The saving for a 23-year-old would depend on the final rate or threshold, and on how far the phase-in had progressed.
Would a rate cut or a higher threshold help young people more?
It depends on the design. A rate cut helps all eligible employers equally. Widening the zero-rate band helps low-paid roles most, and young people are concentrated in those roles. Which path the report chooses, and how quickly, will shape the economics for employers.
Are higher employer national insurance costs really the main reason for weak youth hiring?
That is contested. From April 2025 the employer rate rose to 15% and the threshold fell to £5,000. Hospitality and retail groups say this, along with minimum wage rises, made entry-level hiring costlier. Other factors also matter, so the report will need to justify its reasoning.
Why does it matter if so many young people are not in work or education?
Long spells out of work early in a career can scar later earnings and job prospects. There is also a public finance cost, because lost earnings mean lost tax receipts and higher spending on benefits such as Universal Credit. Roughly 950,000 16-to-24-year-olds were NEET in early 2025.

