The Neets review led by Alan Milburn is one of the most politically loaded policy exercises in Westminster, because it asks why close to a million young people in the UK are neither studying nor working. The BBC’s Laura Kuenssberg argues that the review will not be for the faint-hearted and will test Andy Burnham’s appetite for a welfare fight. She also points out that Milburn is not the first to try to fix the problem, so the question is what is different this time. This article treats the review as a process: what it must define, diagnose, design and deliver, and where each stage is likely to run into political resistance.
What the Neets Review Is and Why It Matters Now
The term NEET, meaning not in education, employment or training, covers a heterogeneous group. It includes a young carer, a graduate between jobs, a teenager with an undiagnosed learning difficulty, and a 23-year-old with severe anxiety who has not worked since leaving school. The category is a statistical convenience, which is the first reason the review is hard. A single label hides very different causes.
The Office for National Statistics publishes the official estimates through its labour market releases. Recent estimates put the number of 16 to 24-year-olds in this group at roughly 900,000 to 950,000, around one in eight of that age group. Exact figures change every quarter and carry sampling uncertainty, so any claim about a record or a trend should be checked against the latest release.
Who Is Alan Milburn and Why Was He Chosen?
Alan Milburn served as Health Secretary under Tony Blair and later became a prominent voice on social mobility. He is an insider with a reputation for reform and for pushing against institutional inertia. That reputation suits a review the Labour government wants to be seen as serious rather than cosmetic. It also means he will be judged against his own record and against the many earlier attempts.
Why Earlier Attempts Fell Short
Every government since the late 1990s has tried to bring down youth inactivity. The table below summarises the main programmes and the lesson each offers.
| Initiative | Period | Core idea | Lesson for the current review |
|---|---|---|---|
| New Deal for Young People | From 1998 | Mandatory options for 18 to 24-year-olds after six months on jobseeker benefits | Conditionality can work when jobs are plentiful, but it depends on the labour market |
| Education Maintenance Allowance | Nationwide from 2004, ended in England in 2011 | Weekly payments to keep poorer 16 to 18-year-olds in education | Financial support affects staying-on rates, but it is easy to cut when budgets tighten |
| Future Jobs Fund | 2009 to 2011 | Subsidised jobs created after the financial crisis | Paid work experience can help, but programmes tied to one downturn rarely last |
| Raising the participation age | 2013 and 2015 in England | Legal duty to remain in education or training until 18 | A duty to participate does not guarantee suitable provision |
| Kickstart Scheme | 2020 to 2022 | Funded six-month placements for young people on Universal Credit | Large placement schemes can scale quickly, but they do not address underlying health or skills barriers |
The pattern is that policy tends to follow the economic cycle. Schemes are launched after a shock such as the Great Recession or the COVID-19 pandemic, then wound down once headline unemployment recovers. The current problem is different. Youth inactivity has risen even though overall employment has been comparatively resilient, which suggests structural causes that cyclical schemes do not reach.
How the Neets Review Has to Work: A Step-by-Step Analysis
Step 1: Agree What the Number Actually Measures
A credible review starts by breaking the headline figure into segments. ONS data have long shown that a substantial share of NEETs are economically inactive rather than unemployed. In practice that means they are not looking for work, often because of ill health, caring duties or study that does not appear in the NEET definition. Those who are actively seeking work need a very different response from those who are not.
The review therefore has to separate at least four groups:
- Short-term transitional young people, who are between courses or jobs and need little help.
- Unemployed jobseekers, who need matching, training and employer demand.
- Health-limited young people, who need clinical and supported-employment pathways.
- Disengaged young people, often with a history of school exclusion, who need relationship-based support.
Step 2: Diagnose the Causes Without Prejudging Them
This is where the politics becomes sharpest. Several explanations compete, and the evidence for each is partial.
Health and mental health
Many analysts point to rising reported mental ill health among young people and long waits for treatment. Others warn that the evidence on causes, including the role of diagnosis and changing reporting habits, is still contested. The review will have to avoid treating health explanations as either excuses or the whole story.
Education and special needs
Weak attainment in further education, unmet learning needs and school exclusion are strongly associated with later disengagement. The pipeline problem starts well before age 16.
Labour market and employer incentives
Entry-level jobs have been squeezed in some sectors. Some employer groups argue that higher employment costs, including the April 2025 rise in employer National Insurance and increases to youth minimum wage rates, make taking on inexperienced workers less attractive. Others dispute how large that effect is. The honest position is that the evidence is still developing.
Benefit design
The structure of Universal Credit and health-related benefits shapes incentives for young people. It also shapes how they interact with the Department for Work and Pensions. This is the area most likely to trigger a fight inside the Labour Party.
Step 3: Design Interventions That Match Each Segment
Previous programmes often applied one model to everyone. A better design would pair specific tools with specific groups:
- Early identification in schools and colleges, using attendance and attainment data to flag risk before a young person leaves the system.
- A single named adviser for each young person, echoing the logic of the old Connexions service.
- Paid work experience and quality apprenticeships with clear progression routes.
- Integrated health and employment support for those with mental health conditions.
Step 4: Confront the Welfare Trade-Offs
This is the step Kuenssberg’s analysis highlights. Any serious attempt to reduce inactivity eventually touches welfare, and the question is how far support should be tied to participation. A conditionality-heavy approach echoes the logic of the Welfare Reform Act 2012 and risks alienating Labour MPs and disability campaigners. A support-heavy approach with weak obligations risks the charge that nothing has changed.
Whichever way it leans, the review will have to say clearly whether it believes the main barrier is motivation, capability or opportunity. Those three diagnoses lead to three very different policies.
The politics are made harder by the profile of those involved. Andy Burnham has a reputation as a regional leader focused on opportunity and fairness. A review that points toward tougher obligations would test that image, while one that rejects them would be tested by those demanding results. Meanwhile Keir Starmer‘s earlier benefit reform difficulties are a reminder that internal opposition can derail even modest changes.
Step 5: Build Delivery and Measurement Into the Plan
Most past schemes failed in delivery rather than design. A workable plan needs funding that survives more than one budget cycle, local authorities and colleges with a clear duty and the data to meet it, and outcome measures that go beyond a single placement. Retention in work or study after twelve months is a far better test than the number of starts.
What Is Different This Time?
Three things distinguish the current exercise from earlier ones. First, the problem is structural, and not simply the aftermath of a recession. Second, health is central to the debate in a way it was not in 1998 or 2009. Third, the review sits alongside broader work on skills and the labour market, including Skills England, which gives it a possible delivery route that earlier efforts lacked.
These advantages do not guarantee success. Reviews led by respected figures often produce thoughtful reports that are then only partly implemented. The distinguishing test is whether the government accepts the uncomfortable recommendations along with the popular ones.
Risks, Edge Cases and Critiques
- Measurement distortion: Focusing on the NEET count can push services to prioritise easy cases and neglect the hardest.
- Regional variation: Rates vary widely across the UK, and a national scheme may fit poorly in areas with few local jobs.
- Displacement: Subsidised placements can replace jobs that would have existed anyway.
- Stigma: Messaging that implies young people are the problem can discourage engagement from those who most need help.
- Time lag: Early-intervention reforms take years to affect the data, which is awkward for any government that wants quick results.
Practical Implications for Employers, Colleges and Local Leaders
Whatever the final recommendations, certain actions make sense now.
- Employers can offer structured entry routes, such as short paid placements with a guaranteed interview, and work with local colleges to define what skills entry-level roles actually need.
- Colleges and training providers should track destinations and drop-out points, then share that data with councils early enough to act on it.
- Local authorities can map the available support for young people and remove duplication between health, education and employment services.
- Analysts and journalists should check the latest official GOV.UK publications and ONS releases before quoting figures, since the numbers are revised.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are NEETs?
NEET stands for not in education, employment or training. It is a statistical category, usually applied to 16 to 24-year-olds, that includes both unemployed jobseekers and economically inactive people who are not looking for work.
Why are so many young people not in work or education?
There is no single cause. Commonly cited factors include mental and physical health problems, unmet special educational needs, weak qualifications, regional job shortages and the cost to employers of hiring inexperienced staff. The relative weight of each is still debated.
Who is leading the Neets review?
Alan Milburn, the former Labour Health Secretary, is leading the review for the Labour government.
Is this the first attempt to reduce youth inactivity?
No. Programmes such as the New Deal for Young People, the Future Jobs Fund and Kickstart all sought to move young people into work. The new review will be judged on whether it addresses the structural causes those schemes largely left alone.
The Real Test Comes After the Report
The most important insight from the analysis is that the hard part of this process is not the diagnosis. Almost everyone accepts that nearly a million young people outside work and study is costly, both to them and to the public finances. The hard part is choosing between competing explanations when each points toward a policy that some part of the governing coalition will resist. Reports are easy to commission and hard to enact.
Readers should watch three things. The first is whether the review segments the NEET population honestly, rather than treating it as one problem. The second is how it handles the link between health-related benefits and young people’s incentives, which is where a welfare fight would begin. The third is whether any recommendation comes with multi-year funding and a named body responsible for delivery. A reasoned prediction is that the review will recommend more integrated, personalised support and that its most contentious proposals will be softened or delayed. The unanswered question is whether Burnham and the government will spend political capital on the parts of the report that are difficult, or only on those that are easy to announce.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is the NEET figure considered a misleading way to measure youth disadvantage?
NEET is a statistical category that lumps together very different people, such as young carers, graduates between jobs, teenagers with undiagnosed learning difficulties and young people with severe anxiety. Because the causes differ so much, one headline number cannot guide targeted policy without being broken into segments first.
How many young people are currently classed as NEET in the UK?
Recent Office for National Statistics estimates put the number of 16 to 24-year-olds at roughly 900,000 to 950,000, about one in eight of that age group. The figures change every quarter and carry sampling uncertainty, so any claim about records or trends should be checked against the latest ONS release.
Why does the article say this problem differs from previous youth unemployment crises?
Past schemes were launched after economic shocks such as the Great Recession or COVID-19 and wound down once unemployment recovered. Today youth inactivity has risen even though overall employment has been fairly resilient, which points to structural causes like health and skills barriers that cyclical, downturn-driven programmes do not reach.
What lessons do earlier programmes like the New Deal or Kickstart offer Milburn?
Each shows a limit. Conditionality under the New Deal depended on plentiful jobs, the Education Maintenance Allowance was easy to cut, and Kickstart scaled quickly but ignored underlying health and skills barriers. The review must therefore design measures that last beyond one budget cycle or downturn.
Why was Alan Milburn chosen to lead the review?
As a former Health Secretary under Tony Blair and a prominent social mobility voice, Milburn has a reputation for reform and challenging institutional inertia. That helps the government present the review as serious rather than cosmetic, though he will be judged against his own record and the many earlier attempts.
Are most NEETs unemployed and looking for work?
Not necessarily. ONS data have long shown that a substantial share of NEETs are economically inactive rather than unemployed, meaning they are not seeking work. Common reasons include ill health, caring duties or study that falls outside the NEET definition, so job-search support alone would miss many of them.

