When Danny Kruger argues that Labour will take the extra Milburn spending and abandon any cuts, he is making a claim that goes well beyond one policy review. He is describing a pattern: a government that promises fiscal discipline, then retreats when the politics get hard. This article examines the claim, the review it refers to, and the wider fight over Labour welfare cuts. We keep established facts apart from political interpretation, because the headline is an argument and not a settled outcome.
One caveat first. The claim comes from a political opponent, and nothing here should be read as a confirmed government decision. The useful question is whether the structure of Labour’s position makes Kruger’s prediction plausible, and what evidence would prove him right or wrong.
Who Is Making the Argument, and Why It Matters
Kruger is a former Conservative MP who Reform UK welcomed after he left the Conservative Party in 2025. He has long written about work, family and the limits of the state. His criticism of Labour is therefore not a reflex. It sits within a coherent right-of-centre view that a generous benefits system can trap people outside the labour market.
His argument has three parts:
- Labour has commissioned a review that is likely to recommend more spending on young people outside work and education.
- The government will accept that spending, because it fits its instincts and its backbenchers’ wishes.
- Labour will then drop or dilute the savings it once promised, leaving the bill higher rather than lower.
Whether or not you agree, this is a sharp reading of how modern governments behave under fiscal pressure. Spending is easy to announce and politically rewarding. Savings are painful, specific and leak support at once.
The Milburn Review: What It Is and What It Is Not
Alan Milburn served as Health Secretary under Tony Blair and later chaired the Social Mobility Commission. He has a reputation as a reformer who tends to mix investment with accountability. The government asked him to examine why so many young people are not working or studying, a group usually described as NEET.
The scale is significant. Estimates from the Office for National Statistics in 2025 put the number of 16 to 24-year-olds who are NEET at roughly 950,000, around one in eight of the age group. Rising mental health referrals, a weak entry-level job market and employer caution all feature in the debate, but experts disagree about their relative weight.
Why a review can become a spending commitment
Reviews of this kind usually do not end in pure cost-cutting. If the diagnosis is that young people are being failed by weak support, the natural remedy is more support: guaranteed placements, mental health services, careers advice and local coordination. Each of these costs money in the short term, even if the promised gain is lower youth unemployment and higher lifetime earnings later.
That is the opening Kruger exploits. If the review recommends investment and the government accepts it, the question becomes who pays. Without offsetting savings, the money comes from borrowing or tax rises.
Why Welfare Cuts Became So Politically Costly for Labour
To see why the prediction has traction, look at the summer of 2025. The government’s welfare package, driven by Chancellor Rachel Reeves‘s fiscal constraints, aimed to restrain the growth in spending on health and disability benefits. It targeted Personal Independence Payment eligibility and changes to health-related elements of Universal Credit.
A large backbench rebellion followed. The government made concessions, narrowed the scope of the changes and postponed the most contentious parts pending a separate review. Much of the projected saving, originally in the region of several billion pounds a year by the end of the decade, was weakened as a result. The episode damaged confidence in the government’s ability to deliver savings, a weakness that Keir Starmer‘s opponents have exploited ever since.
The historical pattern
Welfare retrenchment has always been contested. The post-2010 era of austerity produced measurable savings, and also lasting political resentment on the left. Labour today inherits that memory. For many of its MPs, voting for disability benefit cuts feels like betraying the party’s founding purpose in the welfare state.
This is the strongest argument for Kruger’s thesis. If a government cannot hold its own side on a modest package, it will struggle to defend deeper cuts, and it may prefer to spend on programmes that its own supporters like.
The Fiscal Arithmetic Behind the Debate
The tension is not only political. It is arithmetic. The government has bound itself to fiscal rules, and the Office for Budget Responsibility judges whether the Treasury meets them. Its published forecasts are available on the OBR website. The headroom against those rules is thin, so any extra spending commitment, or any lost saving, can force a choice between tax rises and cuts elsewhere.
The working-age health and disability benefits bill has been one of the fastest-growing areas of public spending. The Department for Work and Pensions publishes the underlying caseload data, and the OBR has repeatedly flagged it as a risk to the public finances. When HM Treasury loses an expected saving in one area and adds a commitment in another, the gap widens twice.
Three ways the gap can be closed
- Higher taxes. Politically costly given the party’s manifesto commitments on working people.
- Higher borrowing. Constrained by the fiscal rules and by the cost of servicing national debt.
- Savings elsewhere. Often the hardest, because the easiest options have already been taken.
Kruger’s prediction implicitly bets that Labour will choose the first or second route, because the third is blocked by its own MPs.
Competing Interpretations
The case for Kruger’s reading
His supporters point out that the government has already reversed course once. They note that spending reviews tend to ratchet upward, and that independent reviews rarely recommend leaving things as they are. On this view, the Milburn report is a convenient justification for spending that the government would like to do anyway.
The case against
Defenders of the government make a different argument. Investment in young people is not the opposite of reform. If it reduces long-term inactivity, it could reduce future benefit costs. Many economists accept that early intervention can pay for itself, although the evidence varies by programme and the savings are often slower and smaller than ministers promise. Labour can also argue that the earlier cuts were poorly designed, not that all savings are impossible.
What the evidence actually supports
The honest position is uncertain. The success of youth guarantees and similar schemes depends on implementation, local labour demand and employer participation. The Employment and Support Allowance experience shows how reforms that look sensible on paper can fail in practice. The same caution applies to both sides of this argument.
Practical Takeaways for Readers
If you follow UK fiscal politics for work or investment, treat the headline as a hypothesis and watch for evidence. Useful indicators include:
- The final wording of the Milburn recommendations. Look for whether they are costed, phased and tied to savings.
- Budget documents and OBR scoring. The OBR’s costings reveal whether any new money is offset.
- Backbench behaviour. Another rebellion would show where the real limits lie.
- Benefit caseload data. Rising claims would strengthen the case for reform, whatever its form.
- Gilt market reaction. Investors usually signal quickly when they doubt fiscal credibility.
A common mistake is to treat a review’s recommendations as government policy. Another is to assume that spending and reform are mutually exclusive. The most meaningful tests are about design: conditionality, outcomes measurement and whether money follows results.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Milburn review?
It is a government-commissioned examination, led by former Health Secretary Alan Milburn, into why so many young people in the UK are outside work and education, and what could be done about it.
Will Labour abandon welfare cuts?
That is Danny Kruger’s prediction, not a confirmed decision. The government has already softened parts of its welfare package after a backbench rebellion, which gives the claim some plausibility. Final decisions will be visible in Budget documents.
How many young people are NEET in the UK?
ONS estimates in 2025 suggested roughly 950,000 people aged 16 to 24 were not in education, employment or training. Figures change each quarter, so check the latest ONS release.
Can youth investment reduce welfare spending?
It can, if programmes move people into sustainable work, but the savings are typically slow and uncertain. Results depend heavily on delivery and local job markets.
The Real Test Is Whether Investment Comes With a Price Tag
Kruger’s headline compresses a sophisticated question into a political jab: can a government add spending and abandon savings without paying in credibility? The strongest part of his case is not about Alan Milburn at all. It is about how Labour handled the summer of 2025, when the party showed it could be forced to retreat.
The weakest part is the assumption that investment in young people is just another spending give-away. If the Milburn proposals are costed, targeted and measured, they could belong to a genuine reform agenda. If they arrive uncosted and alongside a collapsing savings programme, the prediction will look prescient.
Watch the next Budget and the OBR’s verdict on it. The unanswered question is whether Labour can show that more help for young people does not simply mean a larger bill for everyone else. The government’s answer, whenever it comes, will matter far beyond one review.

