The sandpaper scandal is back in the headlines. Cameron Bancroft’s latest allegations have reopened a question many thought settled in 2018: who really knew about the plan to alter the ball at Newlands? As BBC Sport has noted in its overview of who was there and what they have said since, the affair rests on competing recollections, partial admissions and official findings that have never fully satisfied critics. This article sets out what is established, what is disputed and what to watch for as the story develops.
What Happened at Newlands in March 2018
The incident took place on the third day of the third Test between South Africa and Australia at Newlands Cricket Ground in Cape Town on 24 March 2018. Television cameras showed debutant opener Cameron Bancroft rubbing the ball with a small yellow object and then apparently concealing it in his clothing. He first described it as sandpaper, though it was later said to be adhesive tape with granules attached. The episode is documented as the 2018 Australian ball-tampering scandal.
The story went beyond cricket within hours. Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull publicly called the news shocking and disappointing, and sponsors and broadcasters weighed in. Within days the sanctions were announced: a 12-month ban for captain Steve Smith and vice-captain David Warner, and nine months for Bancroft, all imposed by Cricket Australia.
Who Was There: The Key Figures
The question of who was there matters because the official story depends on a narrow chain of knowledge. The table below summarises each figure’s role and the position they have generally taken. It is a simplified guide, and readers should consult the original statements for detail.
| Person | Role in 2018 | Broad position since |
|---|---|---|
| Cameron Bancroft | Opening batter who handled the ball | Accepted responsibility; later comments have questioned how widely the plan was known |
| Steve Smith | Captain | Said the “leadership group” discussed the plan and accepted responsibility |
| David Warner | Vice-captain | Named by Cricket Australia’s investigation as the instigator |
| Darren Lehmann | Head coach | Denied involvement in the plan; resigned after the series |
| Bowling attack | Players on the field | Have said they were not aware of the plan |
The Bowlers
The bowling group is central to the current debate. Pat Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon were the pace and spin options that day, and Cricket Australia’s investigation concluded that they had no prior knowledge. They have consistently held to that account. Because they were the ones who would benefit most directly from a roughened ball, any suggestion that they knew carries unusual weight.
The Wider Team
Reports at the time said that Peter Handscomb relayed to the dressing room that Bancroft had been caught on the big screen, prompting a message to the field. The wicketkeeper Tim Paine, who later became Test captain, was also on the field. These details show how many people were physically close to the event, even if the official finding is that very few were involved in planning it.
Who Said What Since 2018
The Immediate Admissions
The first public account came from Smith, who said the leadership group had discussed the idea and that he had let it go ahead. He was visibly emotional at the press conference, and the phrase “leadership group” became a point of lasting dispute because it implied more than two people. Bancroft apologised publicly and accepted that he had made a serious mistake. Warner issued his own statement of apology, but it was Cricket Australia’s investigation that named him as the instigator and the one who showed Bancroft how to do it.
Cricket Australia’s Findings
Cricket Australia’s head of integrity carried out the original inquiry, and the governing body concluded that three players were responsible. It cleared Lehmann of involvement in the plan, although he resigned from his role. The organisation then commissioned a separate cultural review by The Ethics Centre, which criticised a win-at-all-costs culture in the national team and an imbalance between winning and ethical behaviour. This review is useful because it explains why people were willing to accept a narrow explanation for a team-wide culture.
The Long Tail of Doubt
Questions never fully disappeared. Bancroft’s later interviews hinted that the story was less simple than the official version, and in 2021 his comments prompted renewed scrutiny from the bowlers, who again denied knowing. Cricket Australia’s response at the time was that nothing new had emerged to justify reopening the case. Warner’s lifetime leadership ban also stayed contentious for years, with critics arguing that it was disproportionate and supporters saying it reflected the seriousness of his role.
Cameron Bancroft’s Allegations: Why They Matter Now
The latest Cameron Bancroft allegations matter for three reasons. First, they come from the player at the centre of the incident, who has little to gain by making the story more complicated. Second, they challenge the claim that the plan was confined to a small group. Third, they test whether Cricket Australia’s findings can survive new testimony.
It is important to separate established fact from contested claim. The facts are the footage, the three bans, and Cricket Australia’s published conclusions. The contested part is whether others knew, and what “knowing” means in practice. A bowler who sees a teammate treat the ball, or who is told casually that something is planned, is in a different position from one who helped design the plan. Without documents, recordings or messages, the dispute becomes one person’s recollection against several denials. Readers should therefore check each reported claim against the original interview wording, not rely on headlines.
Why Altering the Ball Matters in Cricket
The law against ball tampering exists because the condition of the ball directly affects the contest. A roughened side helps swing bowling, especially reverse swing, because it creates an imbalance in airflow around the ball. Bowlers legitimately maintain one side by polishing and keeping it dry, but using a foreign object such as sandpaper or tape breaches the Laws of Cricket. The ball itself is a precisely specified item, as the entry on the cricket ball explains.
The effect of tampering on any single delivery is hard to prove, which is partly why the penalty system has historically been light. In 2018 the International Cricket Council imposed a one-match suspension and a fine on Smith, while the heavier bans came from the domestic governing body. That gap in approach shows how much of the punishment was driven by reputation and public pressure, not by the technical impact on play.
Lessons for Teams and Governing Bodies
The case is a useful reference for anyone working in sport governance. Several lessons stand out:
- Define leadership accountability clearly. The vague phrase “leadership group” allowed the debate to continue for years.
- Record investigations transparently. Published reasoning, including why certain people were cleared, reduces later suspicion.
- Protect junior players. Bancroft was a debutant with little standing; cultures where juniors carry out risky tasks invite poor decisions.
- Plan for reopened cases. Governing bodies should have a clear threshold for when new testimony justifies fresh review.
Common mistakes include treating a punishment as the end of an inquiry, and assuming that an official finding can settle every question about culture. The Ethics Centre review was, in effect, an acknowledgement that behaviour on the field reflects the environment off it.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who was involved in the sandpaper scandal?
Cricket Australia concluded that Bancroft, Smith and Warner were involved in the plan. Warner was named as the instigator. Others, including the bowlers and the coach, were found not to have had prior knowledge, though that finding has been questioned.
What did Cameron Bancroft actually do?
He was filmed using a small object to rub the ball during the third Test in Cape Town and attempting to hide it. The object was later described as adhesive tape with granules, not true sandpaper.
What punishments were handed out?
Smith and Warner received 12-month bans from Cricket Australia, and Bancroft received nine months. Lehmann resigned as coach after the series.
Did the bowlers know about the plan?
Cricket Australia’s investigation found they did not, and the bowlers have repeatedly said so. Bancroft’s latest comments have raised questions, but they have not changed the official finding at the time of the BBC’s reporting.
The Question That Outlasts the Scandal
The most important insight from the story is that the sandpaper scandal has never been only about one piece of tape. It is about whether a sports organisation can close a case when the people closest to it keep telling the story differently. Bancroft’s allegations do not prove that others knew, but they make it harder to treat the 2018 findings as the last word.
The next developments to watch are straightforward. Does Cricket Australia respond with a formal review or a statement that nothing new has emerged? Do any teammates adjust or expand their earlier accounts? And does any documentary evidence surface that would move the debate from recollection to record? A sensible prediction is that, absent new evidence, the official position will stay unchanged, but the reputational cost of unresolved doubt will continue to build. The unanswered question is whether anyone involved still has a reason to say more, and what it would take for them to do so.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does the phrase "leadership group" still matter in this debate?
Steve Smith used it in his 2018 press conference, implying that more than two people discussed the plan. Cricket Australia's investigation, however, held only three players responsible. That gap between the phrase and the official finding is why critics still question how widely the plan was known.
Was the object really sandpaper?
Bancroft first described it as sandpaper, but it was later said to be adhesive tape with granules attached. Either way, the television footage showed him rubbing the ball and apparently hiding the object in his clothing, and that was the basis for the sanctions.
Why are the bowlers so central to the current discussion?
Pat Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon would have benefited most directly from a roughened ball. Cricket Australia concluded they had no prior knowledge, and they have kept to that account, so any suggestion they knew would carry unusual weight.
Did Darren Lehmann face sanctions for the incident?
No. Cricket Australia cleared the head coach of involvement in the plan, and he denied any. He did resign after the series, though. Separately, a cultural review by The Ethics Centre criticised a win-at-all-costs culture within the team.
What penalties were handed out and who imposed them?
Cricket Australia imposed the sanctions within days: a 12-month ban each for captain Steve Smith and vice-captain David Warner, and a nine-month ban for Cameron Bancroft. Warner was named as the instigator who showed Bancroft how to carry out the act.
How many people were close to the event, and does that change the official finding?
Many were physically close. Peter Handscomb reportedly relayed to the dressing room that Bancroft had been shown on the big screen, and Tim Paine was on the field. Even so, the official finding remains that very few people were involved in planning it.

