Joanne Young‘s daughter has joined her mother in calling for a change to the law on consent, following the Joanne Young rape case. The public details available so far are limited, so this article does not speculate about the facts of the case. It looks at the legal and policy questions that campaigns like this raise: how consent is defined, how it is tested in court, and what reform could realistically change.
Why the Joanne Young Case Has Put the Law on Consent in Focus
A mother and daughter campaigning together is a reminder that rape affects families as well as individual survivors. Their call targets a basic question: what does the law require before sexual activity is considered lawful? The answer varies between jurisdictions, and those differences shape how sexual assault cases are investigated, charged and tried.
How Consent Is Defined in UK Law
In England and Wales, the Sexual Offences Act 2003 says a person consents if they agree by choice, and have the freedom and capacity to make that choice. The wording appears in section 74 of the Act. Scotland uses a similar “free agreement” standard in the Sexual Offences (Scotland) Act 2009. Northern Ireland has its own framework under the 2008 Sexual Offences Order.
The Role of Reasonable Belief
Prosecutors must usually show two things. The complainant did not consent, and the defendant did not reasonably believe that they did. This second test concerns the defendant’s mens rea, or mental state. It can become the main battleground at trial, because it shifts attention to what the accused says they perceived.
Where Campaigners Say Consent Legislation Falls Short
Reform advocates generally raise three concerns. These are general criticisms of consent laws, not claims about any one case.
- Vague standards: “Freedom and capacity” is open to wide interpretation by juries.
- Unequal scrutiny: Questioning can focus on the complainant’s behaviour rather than the defendant’s actions, a pattern often linked to victim blaming.
- Passive responses: Law and public understanding may not reflect how people actually react to assault.
The Freeze Response
Research on tonic immobility suggests many survivors cannot move or speak during an attack. A 2017 Swedish study of women attending a Stockholm clinic after sexual assault reported that a majority experienced significant immobility. If juries expect visible resistance, such evidence matters. It is also why advocates favour tests that look at what the defendant did to ensure agreement.
Affirmative Consent: A Possible Direction for Reform
One much-debated model is affirmative consent, which asks whether a person actively agreed, rather than whether they said no. Supporters argue it clarifies expectations and reduces reliance on resistance. Critics worry it could be hard to apply and might blur the line between civil expectations and criminal consent.
Lawyers also stress that any redefinition must respect the presumption of innocence and the prosecution’s burden of proof. The legal standard in criminal trials remains proof beyond reasonable doubt. A clearer definition of consent does not lower that threshold. It changes what must be proved.
What Law Reform Can and Cannot Achieve
Changing a statute is only part of the answer. Evidence from other reform efforts suggests outcomes depend on several linked factors:
- Police practice: how complaints are recorded and investigated.
- Prosecution decisions: how bodies such as the Crown Prosecution Service assess cases.
- Court procedure: limits on questioning, as with rape shield laws.
- Jury education: judicial directions that counter common myths.
- Victim support: access to specialist advocates and services.
The Law Commission and parliamentary committees have often been the route through which such proposals are examined before legislation is drafted.
Practical Steps for Supporters of Consent Reform
Readers who want to engage with the issue can start with a few practical steps:
- Read the statutory definition of consent in your own jurisdiction.
- Follow consultations by law reform bodies and justice committees.
- Write to elected representatives with specific proposals rather than general appeals.
- Support specialist services, and avoid sharing details that could identify survivors.
FAQ: Consent Law and Reform
What is the legal definition of consent in England and Wales?
Under the Sexual Offences Act 2003, consent means agreeing by choice with the freedom and capacity to make that choice.
Why do people want the law on consent changed?
Campaigners argue current tests are too vague and put too much scrutiny on complainants’ behaviour. They want standards that focus on how the accused ensured agreement.
Does changing the law make convictions easier?
Not automatically. Reform may clarify the test, but outcomes also depend on evidence, investigation quality and jury understanding.
The Question That Will Decide the Debate
The call from Joanne Young and her daughter adds a family voice to a long-running argument. The central question is not whether consent matters but whether the law’s wording and courtroom practice reflect how consent works in real life. Watch for whether any government or law reform body takes up the proposal formally, and whether evidence from jurisdictions that have changed their consent standards shows measurable effects on reporting and prosecution. The most likely outcome is gradual: if reform comes, it will probably combine clearer statutory language with better training and court procedure, rather than a single legal fix. Whether that is enough is the question the next round of consultations will have to answer.
Frequently Asked Questions
Would changing the legal definition of consent make it easier to secure rape convictions?
Not automatically. A clearer definition changes what prosecutors must prove, but it does not lower the standard of proof beyond reasonable doubt. Outcomes also depend on police practice, prosecution decisions, court procedure, jury directions and victim support, so statute reform is only one part of the picture.
What is the difference between the current consent test and affirmative consent?
Under current UK law, a person consents if they agree by choice and have the freedom and capacity to do so. Affirmative consent asks whether someone actively agreed, rather than whether they said no. Supporters say this reduces reliance on resistance, while critics say it may be hard to apply.
Why does the defendant's reasonable belief matter so much at trial?
Prosecutors usually have to show both that the complainant did not consent and that the defendant did not reasonably believe they did. This second test concerns the defendant's state of mind, so the trial can turn on what the accused says they perceived, which makes it a central battleground.
How does the freeze response relate to arguments for reforming consent law?
Research on tonic immobility suggests many survivors cannot move or speak during an assault. A 2017 Swedish study reported significant immobility in a majority of women attending a clinic. If juries expect visible resistance, this evidence matters, which is why advocates favour tests focused on what the defendant did.
Does affirmative consent threaten the presumption of innocence?
Lawyers say any redefinition must respect the presumption of innocence and the prosecution's burden of proof. A new definition would change what has to be proved, not who has to prove it. The prosecution would still need to establish guilt beyond reasonable doubt.
Who examines proposals to change consent law before it reaches Parliament?
Bodies such as the Law Commission and parliamentary committees have often examined such proposals before legislation is drafted. They review how the current law works, consider the evidence and options, and make recommendations that can shape any bill later put before lawmakers.

